rakou
All posts
November 11, 20267 min read

Why you hit fat and thin shots, and how to hit the ball first

Chunk one, blade the next. It feels like you have two completely different faults taking turns, and it is the most demoralizing pattern in amateur golf because no single fix seems to touch it. There is a reason for that. They are the same mistake, missed in two directions.

Fat and thin shots come from one thing

Every golf swing has a lowest point in its arc. With an iron, good players put that low point a few inches past the ball, which is why their divot starts after the ball and not before it. The club is still descending when it meets the ball.

If your low point moves around, you have a problem that shows up in two ways:

  • Low point behind the ball. The club reaches the bottom too early, hits the ground first, and the shot goes nowhere. Fat.
  • Low point too far behind, or you compensate. Sensing the ground coming, you pull up through impact. Now the club catches the ball on the way up, on its leading edge. Thin, or topped.

This is why alternating between them is so common. The second miss is usually your body correcting for the first one. Chasing them as separate faults is how golfers spend years going in circles.

What moves your low point

Weight hanging back. If your weight is still on your trail foot at impact, the bottom of the arc sits behind the ball, because the arc travels with your center. Very often this is someone trying to help the ball into the air, which is precisely backwards.

Sliding instead of turning. This is the big one. If your upper body moves several inches away from the target going back, you now have to move it exactly the same distance forward, perfectly, every time, just to get back to where you started. Sometimes you manage it. Usually you do not. The difference between a shoulder turn and a sway is the single biggest cause of inconsistent contact in amateur golf.

Standing up through impact. Losing your posture raises the whole arc, which is the classic route to a topped shot. Often it is a mobility problem rather than a technique one, the body finding room it could not create by rotating.

Scooping. Trying to lift the ball with your hands, adding loft at the last moment. A golf club is already a wedge-shaped lifting device. It does not need your help.

How to hit the ball first

  1. Turn, do not slide. Your chest rotates over a stable center going back. If your head drifts several inches away from the target, that is the fault to fix before any of the others.
  2. Get your weight forward coming down. By impact most of your weight should be through your lead side. The feeling for most amateurs is exaggerated, almost like you are hitting off your front foot.
  3. Keep your sternum ahead of the ball. This is the simplest thought that reliably moves the low point forward. Chest over or slightly past the ball at impact.
  4. Keep turning through. Deceleration is what produces the scoop. Rotate to a full finish and the hands stay passive on their own.
  5. Trust the loft. The club gets the ball airborne. Hit down and the ball goes up, which is the least intuitive true thing in golf.

Practicing it without a ball

Two of the four causes above are pure movement patterns: rotating rather than sliding, and transferring weight. Neither needs a ball, a club or a range, which means both can be trained in the days between rounds rather than only on the rare afternoon you make it to a range. That is the whole argument in the ten-minute daily routine.

Be precise about what Rakou can do here. It cannot see your contact, it does not know whether you took a divot, and it will never tell you the strike was pure. The phone is the club: hold your iPhone like a grip and make a real swing, and it reads the phone's face, your hand speed against your own usual swing and your tempo. The steady rhythm helps with this fault, because a hurried transition and a decelerating finish are what pull people up and out of the turn. Rakou's metronome drill times a 3 to 1 rhythm with the phone in your hand, and the mirror reads your posture face-on with the camera. Neither measures impact. More in swing your phone.

For the body, Rakou can also read a swing you film from behind: ten checkpoints against your own body, a score out of 10, a replay that stops at each checkpoint and one priority with a drill. The club is not tracked, so it reads your movement, not your contact.

The short version

Fat and thin are not two faults. They are one moving low point, missed early and missed late, with the second miss often a correction for the first. The low point travels with your center, so it stays put when you rotate around a stable middle and move your weight forward through impact. Train the turn and the transfer away from the course, and let the range confirm the contact.

Common questions

Why do I hit fat and thin shots?
Both come from the same cause: the bottom of your swing arc is not in a repeatable place. Hit the ground before the ball and it is fat, catch it on the way up and it is thin. They feel like opposite mistakes and they are the same mistake missed in two directions.
What causes chunking the golf ball?
Usually your weight hanging back on the trail foot through impact, or your upper body sliding away from the target in the backswing and not getting back. Both move the low point of the swing behind the ball, so the club reaches the ground first.
How do I stop topping the ball?
Stop trying to help it into the air. Thin and topped shots often come from lifting through impact to scoop the ball up, when loft is what gets it airborne. Keep your chest turning through and let the club do the lifting.
How do I hit the ball first, then the turf?
Get your weight moving towards the target as you come down, and keep your sternum ahead of the ball at impact. With an iron the divot should start after the ball, not before it, which only happens when the low point sits in front of where the ball was.
Can I fix inconsistent contact practicing at home?
The cause, yes. A moving low point usually traces back to swaying instead of rotating and to weight that never transfers, and both are movement patterns you can train without a ball. The contact itself still needs a range to confirm.

Practice the turn and the rhythm

Swing the phone like a club, or film a swing from behind. Ten minutes, no clubs.

Get Rakou